( Click here to download the podcast )
How do you judge if a school is good or bad? A strong leader, great teachers, a diverse curriculum and happy children can all be indicators that a school is good — but when state and federal policymakers evaluate schools, they typically consider just one piece of evidence: test scores.
But are test scores a reliable measure of success? We went to the South Bronx to find out.
RELATED CONTENT
John Merrow’s Blog
John Merrow goes into deeper detail about how this piece was produced, including asking whether the situation described here is a paradox — or a genuine contradiction. READ
“The Math Blackout” Newscast
One of the 11 after-school clubs at P.S. 1 helps students create their own broadcasts. Here, Olga Rojas and classmates report on an imagined school-wide “math blackout.” WATCH




June 6, 2011 at 2:55 pm
Brian Beabout says:
Thanks for bringing up a central issue that gets almost NO attention in school reform debates: our goals for public schools and how to smartly collect data to track performance. Interesting links on this issue:
A recent RAND study on multiple measure’s of school performance: http://bit.ly/knilS7
A summary of my work on site-visitation as a model for school accountability:
ftp://fs.uno.edu/visitations_UCEA_proposal2011.pdf
Rhode Island’s SALT Program: http://www.ride.ri.gov/psi/salt/default.aspx
Catalpa, Ltd. http://www.catalpa.org